Desserts
Pumpkin Puree Recipes | 6 Sweet Ways to Use a Can of One-Pie
Every fall, we New Englanders rely on One-Pie for the pumpkin goodness in all of our favorite pumpkin puree recipes. Here are six to try.
By Aimee Tucker|Oct 12 2021|
Pumpkin Puree Recipes | 6 Sweet Ways to Use a Can of One-Pie
Photo Credit: Aimee Tucker
Photo Credit : Aimee Tucker
6 Favorite Pumpkin Puree Recipes
Photo Credit : Heath Robbins
Pumpkin Whoopie Pies
Savor the flavor of fall with these whoopie pies, a spin on the traditional chocolate version. You’ll love the maple cream cheese filling sandwiched between the pumpkin spice cakes.
Photo Credit : Heath Robbins
Pumpkin Chiffon Pie
Ready to take a break from traditional pumpkin pie (delicious as it is)? We first ran the recipe for pumpkin chiffon pie more than 10 years ago, and it has remained a staff and reader favorite ever since. With its sweet walnut crust and light, fluffy filling, it’s a fresh take on a holiday favorite and worthy of a repeat appearance.
Photo Credit : Aimee Tucker
Soft Pumpkin Cookies
We love these tasty, spicy, soft pumpkin cookies made with pumpkin puree and packed with nuts, raisins, or chocolate chips.
Photo Credit : Aimee Tucker
Pumpkin Streusel Bars
Pumpkin pie meets cookie bars in these delectable pumpkin bars finished with a crumbly, crunchy streusel topping.
Photo Credit : Heath Robbins
Pumpkin Cream Cheese Roll
This autumn-hued pumpkin roll recipe with a maple-sweetened cream cheese filling can be served year-round but is particularly suited for the Thanksgiving table.
Photo Credit : Aimee Tucker
Harborside House Pumpkin Bread
The sweet tang of dried fruit combines with the richness of pumpkin to create this delightful pumpkin bread from the Harborside House bed-and-breakfast in Marblehead, Massachusetts. Are you a fan of One-Pie? Which pumpkin puree recipes are your favorites? This post was first published in 2017 and has been updated.SEE MORE: One-Pie Canned Pumpkin Puree | History and Recipes 5 Best Pumpkin Festivals in New England Best Pumpkin Recipes | 12 Sweet Fall Favorites
Where can I buy One Pie Pumpkin?
I would search for the one pie company’s web site and check with them. In New England you would find it in most major grocery stores.
70 years ago in New York State my grandmother used nothing but One Pie, now I live in CA. and can’t find it anywhere. When I visit my daughter in MA., I bring a few cans home with me. It is the best.
One pie also has canned squash which my family used for our traditional squash pie that is much lighter tasting then pumpkin pie as the only spice used is nutmeg. Very tasty. Regarding canned pumpkin, for extra potassium, I add half a can to my spaghetti sauce and also to soups that I make either with chicken broth or diced tomatoes. I haven’t tried it yet with beef stew, but I have tried using a whole can and it is too much. Besides I freeze the other half for next time I make soup or sauce. It helps make it thicker and tastier.
Love Love all the stories
My family always use One Pie Squash and called it pumpkin pie. Both are good, but I agree the sqash is lighter flavored.
The One Pie pumpkin pie recipe printed right on the can is the best! It uses molasses and no cloves, which many other recipes call for (including another major canned pumpkin manufacturer I won’t name). It’s the only pumpkin pie recipe I’ll use. Perfect every time.
Agreed!
I have not seen this yet, but sure I will get ideas and appreciate.
I am sure I will use and enjoy. Thank you
I use canned pumpkin to keep my dog “ regular” and augment taste in her diet. Always added to my dogs diet for variety, taste and texture but pumpkin ???? is a particular favorite with Veterinarians.
I noticed that One Pie has gone gluten free. I wonder if there has been a change in their recipe. Something added, or removed.
why would there be gluten in pumpkin?
Big Y Supermarket in Ansonia, CT is closing their downtown location and moving to a new location. Everything is 50% off and they have 16 cans of One Pie Squash still for .99/can!
My son , Rob, since he was a little boy, has always requested pumpkin pie in lieu of birthday cake, but only from one recipe, based on One Pie pumpkin. He turns 61 next week and for, about the 51st time, I’ll make him two pumpkin pies, one just for him, and one to share with his friends. Of course I’ll be making them again for Thanksgiving and Christmas too!
What a wonderful note – happy birthday to Rob!
Every NOVEMBER I GO “home “ to NH.Always buy a case of one pie squash and I pie pumpkin. My friend who introduced me to,the squash passed away recently No trip this year because of COVID. Will have to used other brands, I love all the pumpkin recipes.,
My Mom always used One-Pie Squash instead of pumpkin. It made a milder “pumpkin” pie. No cloves either…
Having moved to Texas from Maine, I always bring back to Texas enough One Pie Pumpkin to last a year and family members bring me some also when they come to visit. Other brands don’t compare to One Pie brand.
My mom always used One Pie Squash…it made the most wonderful pie. Living in Florida now has been a challenge…nothing like One Pie here. Family sends it to me now ! Nothing else compares!
Yes! This has been a Thanksgiving staple in my family and my mom sends me a can or two of the squash one every year:) I now carry on this tradition for squash pie every year in VA!
Enjoy all the stories and comments! Have tried 2 of above recipes,they were great.Now will try Aimees recipe for pumpkin streusel bars when I vist my 89 yr. Old sister in Pa. Next week.Nicd to know that some of the older company’s are still around!Happy Baking readers!
The Libby’s canned “pumpkin” is NOT real pumpkin but a combination of squashes. Is One-Pie REAL PUMPKIN?
Looking forward to making many new friends in Reisterstown, MD … I have had more conversations and introductions of a simple, yet elegant, can of deliciousness!!