The Best Lobster Roll in New England is at McLoons Lobster Shack in South Thomaston, Maine

In this segment, see what it takes to achieve lobster roll perfection at McLoons lobster shack in South Thomaston, Maine.

lobster roll from mcloons.

Enter your email to watch the full video

This page is available to registered readers. Enter your email to unlock full access.

Already a subscriber? Sign in

Mayo vs. butter…hot vs. cold…the debate over what makes a good lobster roll and where to find the best lobster roll in New England is never-ending. But in this season 2 segment of “Weekends with Yankee” (episode 203), Amy ends the debate by crowning McLoons lobster shack in South Thomaston, Maine, as the home of the best lobster roll in New England. The logic behind this decision is simple, because McLoons has the best of both worlds. It all starts with a classic New England top-split bun, seared on both sides with butter to form a crispy brown exterior. Then, a layer of mayo is slathered on the inside. Finally, the bun is piled high with fresh lobster meat and, if you prefer, served with a side of butter. Combining butter and mayo makes it a delicious marriage of the two divisions, and a New England classic that’s tough to beat.

About Weekends with Yankee

Produced by GBH, Boston’s preeminent public media producer, Weekends with Yankee is a Telly Award–winner in theTourism/Travel category and was recently nominated for Best New Series and Best Travel Program by The Taste Awards. Series funding for Weekends with Yankee is provided by New Hampshire Division of Travel & Tourism DevelopmentMaine Office of TourismMassachusetts Office of Travel & TourismThe Barn YardAmerican Cruise Lines, and Grady-White Boats.

Black and white compass rose icon with four main points inside a circle on a white background.

Enter your email to continue​

This page is available to registered readers. Enter your email to unlock full access.

You’ll also receive our free daily New England newsletter with stories, seasonal tips, and editor picks.

By continuing, you agree to receive our daily newsletter and occasional updates. View our Privacy Policy.

Unlock Your Roots – One Free Account, Endless Discoveries.

Get access to New England templates, research tools, and more.