In 1892, the “oddly well preserved” exhumed body of Mercy Brown led many to believe she was a vampire responsible for the death of her family in Exeter, Rhode Island.
By Charles T. Robinson
Oct 04 2022
The story of accused vampire Mercy Brown and Rhode Island’s brief tenure as “the Vampire capital of America” was first published as “The Words on Nelly’s Tombstone,” Yankee Magazine, January 1994.
The villagers of Exeter, Rhode Island, knew that farmer George Brown had a problem. First, in 1883 his wife, Mary Brown, succumbed to a mysterious illness. Six months later, his 20-year-old daughter, Mary Olive Brown, also fell ill and died. Within the next several years, his 19-year-old daughter, Mercy Brown, was also dead, and George’s teenage son Edwin Brown, a healthy lad who worked as a store clerk, became suddenly frail and sick. The village doctor informed George that “consumption” was taking his family. But the country folk of Exeter had another explanation.
On a chilly March afternoon in 1892, a group of men entered Exeter’s Chestnut Hill Cemetery. Then they began to exhume the bodies of George Brown’s wife and two daughters. They had concluded that one of the deceased was leaving the grave at night to suck the life out of its relatives. Only by killing the vampire could young Edwin be saved.
First, the men examined the bodies of Mrs. Brown and daughter Mary. Finding them to be properly decomposed, they began to exhume Mercy Brown. Slowly, they shoveled into Mercy’s grave. When they reached the corpse, they suddenly stepped back in terror.
Mercy, who had been buried for more than two months, appeared oddly well preserved. It seemed that her hair and nails had grown. And when the men cautiously prodded the corpse with their shovel, they found that it was filled with fresh blood. The suspected vampire’s heart was removed and burned on a nearby rock. The ashes were added to young Edwin’s medicine. Still, the boy died less than two months later.
To the less superstitious, there was perhaps nothing so unusual about the well-preserved condition of Mercy’s body. She had been in the ground during the two coldest months of the year. The mysterious wave of illnesses that swept George Brown’s family was probably tuberculosis.
But that did not keep Rhode Island from becoming known as the “Vampire Capital of America.” South County, whose isolated villages resembled the lonely hamlets of Transylvania, was a hotbed of vampire rumors between 1870 and 1900. When Bram Stoker, who wrote Dracula in 1897, died, newspaper accounts of vampire Mercy Brown were found in his files.
The legends persist to this day. In Rhode Island Historical Cemetery No. 2 stands the gravestone of alleged vampire Nelly L. Vaughn of West Greenwich, who died in 1889 at the age of 19. The grave is supposedly cursed. One local university professor who studied vampirism claimed that no vegetation or lichen would grow on Nelly’s grave, despite numerous attempts to plant there. And people are still taken aback by the inscription along the bottom of Nelly’s tombstone. The curious words read, “I am waiting and watching for you.”
Have you ever heard of “New England vampire” Mercy Brown?
The story of accused vampire Mercy Brown and Rhode Island’s brief tenure as “the Vampire capital of America” was first published as “The Words on Nelly’s Tombstone,” Yankee Magazine, January 1994, and has been updated.